Red palm oil is one of the latest superfood trends being discussed by health-oriented people and within the natural health community. As we break down the myth that all saturated fat is bad, we are now more willing and eager to consider tropical oils like red palm oil, which is primarily saturated-fat-based. Miraculous health claims and nutritious benefits of palm oil compete for our attention, but do they tell the whole story? In this article, I will present the many sides of red palm oil you should consider before deciding whether to include it in your diet.
About Red Palm Oil
Palm oil is an edible vegetable oil derived from the fruit of the oil palms. Some estimates suggest people have used tropical oils like red palm oil and coconut oil for the past 3,000 to 5,000 years. The oil comes mainly from the African oil palm, Elaeis guineensis, which is native to that region. To a lesser extent, it comes from the American oil palm, Elaeis oleifera, and the maripa palms of South America, Attalea maripa. The palm oil plant was introduced to Southeast Asia in 1848, but it did not lead to the start of plantations until the early 1900s. Indonesia is currently the world leader in palm oil production, but Malaysia still leads in palm oil exports. According to the Tropical Traditions company, it is the most widely consumed dietary oil in the world after soybean oil.
When we hear the terms palm oil or red palm oil, we may not all be talking about the same thing. It can refer to different palm varieties, different parts of the palm fruit used, and different processing methods. Therefore, if we want to use any palm oil today, we need to know exactly what we are getting, as the differences are vast in both health and environmental terms.
The first major difference between palm oil—more appropriately termed palm kernel oil- and red palm oil is that palm kernel oil is derived from the kernel or seed of the fruit, whereas red palm oil is derived from the pulp (flesh) of the same fruit. This difference alone accounts for their distinct color, odor, and flavor. Red palm oil is typically orange-red due to its rich carotenoid content. Palm kernel oil, on the other hand, lacks carotenoids and is not red; it is clear or yellow, depending on how it is refined.
The second difference is their nutritional profiles. The saturated fat content of red palm oil is 40% - 50% saturated, while palm kernel oil is about 81% saturated. (Coconut oil is about 86% saturated fat.)
The third difference is how each is processed, or “refined”. Palm kernel oil is normally refined, deodorized, and bleached, whereas red palm oil is more commonly virgin or unrefined.
These palm oils are also not the same as coconut oil, which comes from the “nut” or “fruit” of coconut palms.
Red palm oil is considered a tropical oil that is liquid to semi-solid at warm or room temperatures, and solid at cooler temperatures. Like other tropical oils, it is rich in saturated fats and includes some monounsaturated fats. The oil is naturally orange-red because of its high beta-carotene content (the same compounds found in yellow, orange, and red vegetables). It has a pronounced flavor that may remind you of carrots, though flavor strength varies with the product’s purity and whether it is used raw or cooked.
Red palm oil resists rancidity, thanks in part to its saturated fat content and high antioxidant content. Its melting point is roughly 24°C (75°F). Its smoke point ranges from 150°C (300°F) to 235°C (450°F). This depends on the refinement used to produce the oil, the quantity used, and how long it is subjected to heat.
Countries of origin tend to use the oil in its natural form, enjoying the robust color, flavor, and odor. In western countries, it is often refined to neutralize its flavor and odor, or bleach its color. This is done simply to “improve” its appearance and acceptance by a society used to light-colored, tasteless fats and oils. In this form, however, it is not beneficial to our health, but harmful.
Red Palm Oil Nutrition
Red palm oil is highly digestible and composed of a mix of saturated and unsaturated fatty acids of the medium- and short-chain varieties. It contains about 40-50% saturated fats, about 40% monounsaturated fats, and about 10% polyunsaturated fats.
When unrefined, or minimally refined, it contains the highest amounts of vitamins A and E of any plant-based oil. In fact, red palm oil is known to be the only oil that has a perfect balance of both tocopherols and tocotrienols, which together compose the many unique forms of vitamin E. Red palm oil is also considered the richest source of beta-carotene in nature, with sources citing that it contains anywhere from 13 - 30 times more vitamin A-producing carotenes than carrots.
It does not require hydrogenation, and naturally contains no trans fatty acids. According to Alpha Health and Okonatur, virgin red palm oil has the following fatty acid profile:
- Lauric MCT (medium chain triglyceride) = 0 - 3%
- Myristic FA (fatty acid) = 1.1%
- Palmitic FA = 43.3 - 44%
- Stearic FA = 4.3 - 5%
- Oleic FA = 39 - 40%
- Linoleic FA (omega-6) = 10 - 10.3%
According to Alpha Health, it has the following vitamin A and vitamin E profile:
- Carotenes 100ppm
- Tocotrienols 400ppm
According to Okonatur, organic, virgin red palm oil contains carotenoid concentrations of 700-1000ppm.
Overall, red palm oil is a source of phytonutrients, antioxidants, natural carotenes (pro-vitamin A), tocopherols and tocotrienols (vitamin E), coenzyme Q10, and omega-3 and omega-6 fatty acids.
NOTE: The nutrition profile of red palm oil will vary significantly depending on the origin of the oil and the processing or refinement applied. The highest-quality oils offer the highest nutrient levels, while low-quality oils may try to piggyback on health claims without delivering the same nutrient amounts.
Red palm oil’s positive nutrition profile, for an oil, does not go unquestioned, as various health experts, organizations, and studies oppose the health claims associated with red palm oil. It is therefore very important to always know what bias or personal stake your source of information may have before taking their information or using it as your personal truth. If a person or company is selling the product, they will certainly make it look and sound as good as possible or overembellish certain claims.
Red Palm Oil Health Benefits
Red palm oil’s nutritional properties may support overall health, including normal growth and cell regeneration, brain health, cardiovascular health, eye health, and skin health.
Based on its high antioxidant activity, beneficial fat profile, as well as some scientific findings, red palm oil:
- may lower cholesterol levels
- may protect against heart attacks
- may protect against strokes
- may help maintain proper blood pressure
- may help improve blood circulation
- may help protect against cancer
- may help protect against osteoporosis and arthritis
- may help protect against asthma and enhance lung health
- may help improve blood sugar control
- may help protect against cataracts and macular degeneration
- may help protect against mental deterioration, like Alzheimer’s
- may help protect against liver disease
- may help improve nutrient absorption
- may help slow down the premature aging processes
- may help protect the skin against damaging UV rays
- may offer immune-boosting benefits
To learn more in detail about some of the supporting and refuting studies, I invite you to read the first two resources listed in the further reading section at the bottom of this essay.
Origin & Processing
Origin
Today, red palm oil mainly comes from one of three geographical locations:
- tropical areas of Africa, like Nigeria
- Southeast Asia, like Malaysia or Indonesia
- tropical areas of South America, like Ecuador
The source location will greatly affect how the oil industry is run, the processing used, and the potential environmental degradation involved.
Organic or Conventional?
According to Nutiva, most palm oil is non-organic, so farmers spray Roundup™ or other harsh herbicides at the base of each tree twice a year. According to Tropical Traditions and Juka’s, sourcing a certified organic farmer in Africa is challenging.
So while we should ideally always buy oils that are organic and virgin, that isn’t simple for red palm oil right now. As you will see from the brand examples I discuss below, it seems we can get either one quality or the other in the oil, but not both (aside from one example).
Currently, palm oil is considered GMO-free.
Virgin or Refined?
Virgin red palm oil is traditionally made by hand-pressing, without extreme heat or chemicals. This allows it to retain natural nutrients like carotenes (precursors to Vitamin A) and tocopherols and tocotrienols (Vitamin E). For optimal health, always choose virgin oil.
Until the early 20th century, palm oil was processed only by traditional methods, where people collected loose fruits from the ground or cut a few bunches from the tree. From the 1920s, however, experimentation began with steam cookers and hand presses designed to make village-level production more efficient in terms of labor use and oil yield. In recent decades, the rapid increase in palm oil production has resulted in large factory settings, where the oil is refined. RBD (refined, bleached, deodorized) palm oil has its nutrients stripped, resulting in a different taste, color, and nutritional profile.
Regardless of whether it is hand-pressed or machine-processed, all red palm oil production goes through the following 4 steps:
Separation of individual fruits from the bunch
- may be carried out manually or mechanically, and may involve some fermentation or sterilizing under steam pressure
Softening of the fruit flesh
- normally involves various forms of cooking, such as steaming or boiling, along with mechanical intervention
Pressing out of the oily liquid
- can be done using various manual or motorized presses/expellers (ex: the Duchscher press, hand-operated hydraulic press, motorized hydraulic press, etc.)
Purification of the oil
- normally involves various settling tanks and centrifuges (and chemicals if RBD oil)
Sustainability Concerns
For starters, for those of us who are conscious and committed to consuming local foods and supporting local economies, red palm oil clearly does not fit that criterion for anyone living outside of the three geographical locations from where it is sourced. If it wasn’t for modern, petroleum-based global transport systems, which have numerous sustainability issues themselves, we would not have the convenience of this product. Of course, it can also be argued that more good comes from supporting those in developing countries by purchasing fair trade and sustainably harvested goods, like red palm oil. Ultimately, there is no clear-cut or black-and-white answer here. Each one of us will need to decide consciously, after considering all sides, what we feel most represents us and the greater good in making our decision about this product.
Secondly, red palm oil (and palm kernel oil) grown in Southeast Asia is today commonly associated with major rainforest and Orangutan habitat destruction. It is at the center of a major sustainability debate, as rainforests are being cleared to grow palm trees. The trend has accelerated in the last decade, as palm oil is used not only for human consumption but also as a biofuel.
Because the oil palm tree was introduced to Southeast Asia, where it has grown successfully, it is mainly harvested there in large, corporate plantations. Being produced and treated like a “large farm operation”, this is part of the big reason why the practices from this region are considered most unsustainable, being driven primarily by profit. Another reason is that forests, including orangutan habitats, are being clear-cut or burned to make space for palm oil plantations.
Third, palm oil as a renewable substitute for petroleum-derived diesel is drawing criticism from organizations worldwide. The 3 core issues involve: 1) the extinction of Orangutans, 2) deforestation, and 3) the food vs. fuel dispute.
While a Roundtable on Sustainable Palm Oil (RSPO) was formed in 2004 to promote the growth and use of sustainable palm oil products, each one of us who is interested in purchasing this oil needs to look for brands that produce it sustainably. It is hard, if not impossible, to support the production, purchase, or use of most palm oil products given the extreme environmental destruction they cause, especially since consuming this product is completely unnecessary. As always, I encourage consumers to read all food and personal care ingredients, as palm oil often appears in many products today.
If you are interested in red palm oil from Asia, look for options that are RSPO certified.
Learn more about the ecological ramifications of red palm oil production.
You can also take an active role in protecting the Orangutans and their habitats by visiting Orangutan Outreach.
Red Palm Oil Uses
Like other tropical oils, red palm oil is credited with being a good cooking oil, as it is considered to be heat-stable. This means it has a high heat tolerance and doesn’t easily break down, oxidize into harmful compounds, or lose its nutritional benefits. To understand this fully, though, we have to look at the full story behind this claim.
It is a commonly held understanding that the more refined an oil is, the higher its smoke point will be, and the less refined it is and more “natural”, the lower its heat stability and smoke point. Therefore, if you are going to buy red palm oil that is virgin, or of the highest quality, you cannot assume that it is safe to be used for any high or prolonged heat use. However, not all sources agree about these facts. Tropical Traditions red palm oil is virgin (unrefined) yet claims to have a higher smoke point than Nutiva’s non-virgin red palm oil.
Second, the longer you use high (or even medium) heat, the more you destroy the oil’s natural antioxidants and healthy fats, defeating the purpose in the first place. If your oil starts to smoke, it begins to denature the fats it contains and generates free radicals that damage your body.
So while virgin oil can be stable under high heat, it is still best used for light to moderate cooking, like stir-frying, sautéing, or gentle grilling. It is not good for any cooking or frying that involves prolonged, high-temperature use. Virgin red palm oil should also not be reused after one frying. Ideally, if we are health-conscious, we avoid subjecting our food to prolonged or high heat, or using oils to cook at all.
If you are going to eat any red palm oil at all, it is best to consume it in its raw or gently cooked form, such as adding it into your meal at the end of cooking.
In its melted or liquid form, you can use it to make salad dressings or drizzle it directly on salads, or add it to soups and stews. Note that its deep reddish-orange color will show up in your meals and will naturally “dye” light foods like quinoa, white mushrooms, potatoes, rice, etc.
In solid form, it can replace similar fat spreads like butter or margarine, and it offers better health benefits.
Red palm oil doesn’t need to be refrigerated and typically stays fresh for months, if not longer, under the right storage conditions (cool, dark place).
Red Palm Oil Brands
There are several red palm oil brands that can be considered “reputable and high-quality” red palm oils on the market today. I will share with you about three brands, which generally meet these criteria. Each, however, possesses quite distinct differences that we should compare and contrast to make the best choice for our optimal, personal use. As you read about each one, you may come to the conclusion that it is not necessarily easy to pick the “best” one out of them. What one makes up for in perhaps better quality, it may lack in professionalism or transparency. Ultimately, all of them do try to make their product sound outstanding, as is the natural tendency for anyone trying to sell a product. It is therefore up to us to be well-informed, discerning consumers and make sure we get what is best not only for us, but also for our Earth. (See more brands in the FAQ section below.)
1. Alpha Red Palm Oil
Alpha Health Products - Red Palm Oil comes from a company out of British Columbia in Canada, founded by Siegfried Gursche. They have specialized in high-quality oils for over 50 years and have led the natural health movement. Their red palm oil comes from Ecuador.
Alpha Red Palm Oil: organic, unrefined, cold-filtered, fairly traded, certified Palm Done Right™, Orangutan-friendly, sustainably made in Ecuador.
2. Okonatur Red Palm Oil
Okonatur is a brand of Organics Overseas, established in 2006 in Miami, Florida, and founded by Angela Ramirez, who has Colombian roots. Their “About” page states that the company has a commitment to environmental stewardship and social responsibility, blending traditional Colombian values with innovative practices. There is a lack of information as to where their red palm oil comes from or how exactly it is extracted or processed.
Okonatur’s Red Palm Oil: mentions it is organic, labeled as “extra virgin”, certified kosher, and part of RSPO.
3. Tropical Traditions
Tropical Traditions - Healthy Traditions is a Wisconsin, US, company founded by Brian and Marianita Shilhavy. Marianita is from the Philippines, and the couple has a direct understanding of traditional tropical oil production, especially coconut oil. They offer a range of natural food and health-related products, with a strong commitment to family farming, organic standards, and sustainable practices. Their red palm oil comes from ** West Africa**, grown on small-scale family farms. However, they don’t provide details on how they extract or process it. They simply state that it is “made in the traditional way”. When I called the Canadian division and asked what this means, I was told the oil is extracted by hand-pressing (manual means), not by any mechanical means.
Tropical Traditions Red Palm Oil: virgin, not-certified organic, glyphosate-tested, from small farms in West Africa.
Reminder: Just as with coconut oil and other trendy foods, companies change their products, and new companies and producers pop up daily. As such, it is impossible to cover them all, or do so accurately, with the market’s rapid changes. So be sure to do your own research to stay up to date on any brand or product you choose to buy.
My Experience with Red Palm Oil
Among the many health-food trends, red palm oil has piqued many people’s curiosity. After some questions from my audience, and out of my own curiosity, I bought a jar of Nutiva’s Organic Red Palm Oil in 2013. (This company no longer offers red palm oil.) I tried it raw first, just as is, on a spoonful. The odor was mild, nothing too distinct or easy to describe. The flavor was not appealing, but it wasn’t unpleasant either. It definitely has a unique flavor that takes some getting used to. The consistency/texture of this red palm oil in its raw form wasn’t smooth and silky, as you’d get with high-quality coconut oil or dairy butter. I suspect this has to do with its source and different fat composition. It almost had a “powdery” texture.
When I used it for light cooking, it was much more pleasant. There was no detectable flavor, and the melted consistency was like any other liquid oil. I tried it with various stir-fry combinations of mushrooms, grains, potatoes, and vegetables. Each time, it made a nice meal and added a rich yellow-orange hue. I also tried it for homemade, stove-popped organic popcorn, which gave most of the popcorn a nice yellow hint of color, but the flavor and residue left a slightly “fatty-like” taste, which was quite unpleasant.
After trying it in various such ways, nothing about this oil stood out as being “worth” the price for our health, wallet, or the environment. It definitely has no place as part of a 100% whole-food, plant-based diet. We can get vitamin A, vitamin E, antioxidants, and all the diverse phytonutrients directly from whole plant foods. Nuts, seeds, avocados, and fresh coconut meat can meet all our fat nutrient needs.
Conclusion
After researching and personally trying one of the popular red palm oil choices available, I can say with certainty that this is not a food product we should rush out to buy or include in our culinary practices on any regular basis. For starters, we should be reducing ALL extracted or isolated oils and oil products in our diets, regardless of how healthy they are claimed to be, and focus instead on whole food sources of healthy fats, like nuts, seeds, avocados, as well as leafy greens, which contain healthy fats, and numerous other plant foods.
Second, we can get everything in this oil from other nutrient sources that may better align with your body’s needs and support environmental sustainability. For example, whole foods like colored vegetables, avocados, sunflower seeds, chia seeds, and hemp seeds offer better-suited sources of vitamin A, vitamin E, and healthy fats, just to name a few.
Third, it doesn’t have a flavor most people would seek out or enjoy. For example, virgin coconut oil has a much nicer flavor, better cooking properties, and avoids much of the environmental destruction that is associated with red palm oil.
Of course, if you feel drawn to red palm oil and feel that it does have a place in your diet, you can decide how you choose to incorporate it for your health. It can be an option for those looking for a healthier cooking oil who don’t want to use virgin coconut oil. It can be a better option for those who want to avoid all seed oils but aren’t comfortable with coconut oil’s high saturated fat content, about 86% for coconut oil versus 40%-50% for red palm oil. It may also be a consideration for those who, for whatever reason, have a hard time getting vitamin A or vitamin E from whole foods in their diet.
In the end, before you make your choice about any newly marketed “miracle health product” our society tries to promote or capture your attention with, you always have to ask yourself 2 important questions:
What are the possible downsides, risks, or negative attributes of this product that are hidden, not focused on, or spoken about?
Can I get the same proposed benefits in some other way that would be more in alignment with my body, health, wallet, sustainability factors, etc.?
There is no need to fall prey to the lucrative marketing and embellished health claims of the numerous products that are pushed in our society today as “healthy” or part of the latest craze. It doesn’t matter whether some company claims how amazing it is, or some celebrity doctor does, or your naturopath, or your best friend. You have to learn about the product yourself from multiple sources and decide, as a conscious and discerning consumer, whether it will enhance your health and quality of life while causing you and our planet the least (if any) harm, or deteriorating it in some way.